top of page
birdyslade

Augustus: What Went Wrong?

Quick Read: The Emperor Who Seized Rome But Couldn't Escape His Own Legacy


The Rise of Augustus


Augustus, also known as Octavian, is remembered as the first Roman Emperor and the architect of Rome’s transformation from a Republic to an Empire. His rise to power began after the assassination of Julius Caesar, his great-uncle and adoptive father. Following Caesar's death, Rome plunged into civil wars, with Augustus emerging victorious. By 27 BCE, he had consolidated power, creating a stable and prosperous Rome after years of chaos.


But while Augustus is often seen as a hero who brought peace and prosperity, things didn’t always go smoothly. Beneath his success, there were several challenges, setbacks, and even failures.


Pop art style image using vibrant colours with an image of Augustus
Emperor Augustus - Not So Perfect After All

Internal Struggles and Power Consolidation


Augustus' early reign was marked by internal struggles. To secure his rule, he entered into the Second Triumvirate with Mark Antony and Lepidus, an alliance that crumbled quickly. His rivalry with Mark Antony, which led to the famous Battle of Actium in 31 BCE, resulted in Antony and Cleopatra’s downfall. While Augustus emerged as Rome’s sole ruler, the battle nearly tore Rome apart, leaving a trail of political purges and violence.


His consolidation of power wasn't straightforward either. Augustus needed to balance the image of restoring the Republic with the reality of becoming a de facto monarch. This delicate act involved manipulating the Senate, which became increasingly symbolic under his reign, losing much of its influence.


Family Troubles and Succession Issues


One of the biggest challenges Augustus faced was within his own family. His marriage to Livia Drusilla was politically motivated, but it didn’t produce any male heirs. Augustus relied on his stepsons and grandsons, but tragedy struck as each potential heir died or fell out of favor.


His favored heir, Agrippa Postumus, was banished, and his adopted sons, Gaius and Lucius Caesar, both died young. This succession crisis left Augustus with limited options, forcing him to adopt Tiberius, a decision he may have regretted. Tiberius, Augustus' eventual successor, was far from the ideal emperor and his reign was marked by cruelty and discontent.


Military Defeats


Despite his reputation as a military genius, Augustus faced significant military setbacks. The most infamous of these was the disastrous Battle of Teutoburg Forest in 9 CE, where three Roman legions were ambushed and annihilated by Germanic tribes. This defeat was a personal blow to Augustus, marking the end of Roman expansion into Germania. It also shook Rome’s confidence, causing Augustus to pull back from further conquests in the region.


The Illusion of Peace


Augustus is credited with establishing the Pax Romana, or Roman Peace, a 200-year period of relative stability and prosperity. But this peace was fragile, maintained by a well-oiled propaganda machine. Augustus' rule was underpinned by a network of loyal military commanders and a complex system of patronage. Behind the scenes, however, there were uprisings in the provinces, political dissent, and unrest among the elite.


Augustus’ efforts to maintain control came at the cost of personal freedoms. His moral reforms, which aimed to restore traditional Roman values, were unpopular and seen by many as invasive and hypocritical.


What Went Wrong?


Despite his immense achievements, Augustus' reign wasn't without flaws. His inability to secure a clear line of succession left Rome vulnerable after his death. His family dynamics were fraught with intrigue and tragedy. His military ambitions, though mostly successful, faced notable defeats, and his "peace" was often maintained through force and manipulation.


In the end, Augustus created a system that depended heavily on his personal rule. When he died in 14 CE, the cracks in the Empire became more apparent under the less competent rule of his successors. Though Augustus is remembered as one of Rome's greatest emperors, his legacy also reveals the fragility of power and the difficulty of sustaining a vast empire.



book cover of How Often Do You Think About The Roman Empire
Simple guide to all things Roman

How Often Do You Think About the Roman  Empire?



Comments


bottom of page